Entangled Manta

Details:
User:
Size:
Added:
18/Apr/2006
Taken:
18/Apr/2006
Comments:
158

back         Send this by E-mail
Description:
We were drifting over a seamount area in about 100 feet of water. The dive had been fairly boring and I was down to about 25% of my air supply. I heard the divemaster start hooting and hollering and pointing off into the blue. I looked and could make out a giant manta. At first I was elated. I had seen a few mantas but never one of the true giants. This one was coming straight at me. As it drew closer I noticed the nets. I realized this would be a valuable photo to illustrate the problems of abandoned nets and took a few photos. My picture taking was interrupted when I noticed the Manta was making incredibly close passes. Finally, it swam just in front of and below me and just stopped! It clearly seemed to be trying to get my attention! The Manta was obviosly in trouble so I stopped taking photos and settled down on it's back. The Manta slowed almost to a stop and began to slowly circle with me resting on it's back. I moved my camera to the crook of my arm and got out my little dive knife clipped to by bouyancy compensator. I started to work on cutting away the net. My knife was small and not especially sharp. I had to saw through the net strand by strand. Soon I had the first section off and it fell away! The net had adhered to the leading edge of the Manta. It was basically in four sections. Three remained. I looked around to see if any of the other divers from my boat were coming to help. They were all just watching. I glanced at my air and saw that I was getting low. I returned to work on the net and was able to free the second section, Now the entire left wing of the Manta was freed. I began working on the right side. The Manta continued making slow circles and was descending. This was not good as I was low on air and had little remaining time before I went into decompression status. I finally got the top right section off and removed it. The lower section that remained was going to be harder because of the severe adhesions to the cephalic lobe and the body of the Manta. I cut a few strands of net away before glancing at my dive computer. The manta had carried me down to over 100 feet. I was out of bottom time (actually in deco status) and almost out of air. I had to go or risk running out of air and or getting the bends. Reluctantly, I lifted off the Manta and swam straight to Ingo, the German divemaster who was with me. I indicated I needed to share air so I could do a safety stop. Ingo gave me his spare second stage and I began my safety stop with one eye on my computer and one on the Manta that continued to circle us. I was still hoping another diver would finish removing the net. When my computer indicated I was in the clear I gestured to Ingo that he should try and cut away the remaining section. He decided to give it a try. Ingo approached the Manta and grabbed the remaining section of net. The net became taught and pulled on the Manta's injured flesh. The Manta recoiled in pain and flapped its wings. Ingo was struck by a wingtip and dropped the net. That was enough for him and he did not approach the Manta again. I bobbed on the surface hoping one of the remaining divers would help. Sadly no one else attempted anything. The Manta made a few more passes then gave up and swam off into the gloom. This was a very strange experience. I felt good that I was able to help but was bitterly dissapointed that I could not finish the job. I think of that Manta often and wonder if he made it. One thing I am sure of is that the Manta approached us with the intent of getting help. It swam straight to us and presented itself to us as if it were at a cleaning station. It actually presented it's back to me. This is very unusual. To me these were clear signs of intelligence and rational behavior. I had always loved Mantas but had never considered that they could be so intelligent. Now there is considerable new information showing that Mantas are extremely intelligent. They can remember divers from year to year and can reognize human faces. It makes it even more sad when we see tham slaughtered senslessly or caught in some abandoned net. I had always dreamed of riding a giant Manta. When my chance came, I couldn't really enjoy it because I had a task to focus on and safety concerns as well. It was no joyride but I will never forget that day. Sorry about the length but I thought this was an interesting story. Currently listed as the most interesting photo tagged with "Manta"
Comments:
ScottS101 says :2/Jan/2011 06:13:28
[http://www.flickr.com/photos/90942251@N00] Thank you for your words and your efforts on behalf of marine mammals!

wleeds9 says :1/Jan/2011 15:37:02
This is truly amazing. As one who works with injured and sick marine mammals, I know how hard it is to help and not feel like you did enough. However, the bit of net you did remove, greatly increased this beautiful animal's chances of survival. You are an ocean hero!!! Your picture should be presented to National Geographic for both it's haunting beauty and it's mesg. Wonderful job!

ScottS101 says :22/Aug/2010 13:46:26
[http://www.flickr.com/photos/yeimaya] I'll let that be your call Gale. You want me to delete it then re-add it to Voices?

yeimaya says :22/Aug/2010 07:42:07
[http://www.flickr.com/photos/24943389@N05] Wonderful response! [http://www.flickr.com/photos/scotts101] Your manta lives!! In the hearts of at least 13,000 people. Is it time to repost it in Voices?

gabriel eisenband says :21/Aug/2010 19:02:21
What a beautiful story , and although saddening that the work was left undone, and that the other divers didn't come in order to help, it was a great honor that you had in helping this great spirit of the seas; reading some of the other comments about animal intelligence, and your post regarding the manta approaching you for help, it seems as if the creature also instantly chose the person with the right will to help and do something. Can they feel us also ? I really congratulate you, I would have done exactly the same and would have tried my best to help this beautiful creature.

yeimaya says :1/May/2010 21:31:04
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Animal Encounters Reader, and we'd love to have this added to the group! I deleted it from Reader and now you can repost it.... gets me every time. Scott did you see the video of the whale that was found beached (maybe a Sei or Brydes whale can't remember)... it is a really tough video to watch because the whale is struggling to breath. It is touching though to see how much effort people make to save it. After it died the found several TONS of plastic grocery bags in its stomach... Oh Scott it is just getting worse and worse isn't it.

yeimaya says :1/May/2010 15:27:10
Did it get into Reader when you reposted it? My pleasure dude. -- Seen in the group"Animal Encounter Gateway" (?)

ScottS101 says :1/May/2010 06:19:18
yeimaya Just so you know, this photo is on it's way to 13,000 comments, thanks to conscientious people like you! Thanks for your support Gale!

yeimaya says :30/Apr/2010 14:40:03
((())) my deep sea buddy! Maybe it will reach 10,000 this photo NEEDS to be seen. -- Seen on your photo stream. (?)

ScottS101 says :30/Apr/2010 14:29:19
Jude's Jewels (back on a little) Jude, thanks for re-inviting this photo. Of all my images I like to promote this one the most, for obvious reasons.

ScottS101 says :30/Apr/2010 14:27:05
yeimaya Plastics in the sea are a growing problem. My last trip to Indonesia (February 2010) the currents streaming past the boat while anchored in some of the straights, looked like a river of trash. It is very disheartening.

yeimaya says :30/Apr/2010 13:50:42
Good words... the more we all talk about this and try to understand the complexity of the tangle the more we can start acting on our own instead... as you said ... counting on experts. There is so much we can all do. One idea is start hammering your grocery store about their plastic bags. Scott I agree this should be on the top again of Reader! And maybe re entered in the Voices photostream. Probably the best way to do it is to delete and reenter it in both groups. As a matter of fact I would encourage you to do it with this photo monthly!!!!!! I just saw a video of a stranded Brydes whale (as I remember) who struggles to breath and finally dies. When the did the autopsy there were several tons of grocery bags in its stomach. I AM DOWNHEARTED AND FURIOUS -- Seen on your photo stream. (?)

Jude's Jewels says :30/Apr/2010 03:49:11
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Animal Encounter Gateway, and we'd love to have this added to the group! Seems I'll help bring this to the surface again. Gale, why not another invite for Gateway where new group members will see it since it's now only in Reader? If it's not the right way of doing this, Gale, just delete the invite part or tell me to & I will. What can I say that others haven't already said? Your story moved me to tears too. I copied, so I could paste "We humans have long underestimated the intelligence of other species and perhaps overvalue our own" to say how true & see Gale has agreed with that too! Only difference is I'd leave out the part on perhaps overvaluing our intelligence. Trust me - we certainly do! If anything, people are becoming stupider as knowledge becomes more abundant. Far, FAR too many people rely on 'experts' to do their thinking for them now & tell them what's best. I wonder if the manta sensed something in you that it didn't in the others & that's why it approached you? Or were you closer to it than the others? I don't believe that animals "smell fear". It's far more complicated than that. But there are similarities in how an animal acts in different situations no matter what species & I'm sure other animals can 'read' to an extent, our intentions (like my visiting possum towards me). The fact you love these magnificent creatures I'm sure was sensed by the manta & in its distress, felt it could trust you. I saw a similar documentary (that Gale referred to) about the amount of plastic even in remote uninhabited areas of our oceans & soil. It was an hour long & this one did trace the microscopic particles of plastics that came from large plastic objects slowly breaking down into smaller & smaller particles. Even such things as fibre from acrylic, nylon & polyester material used for clothing, carpeting, upholstery & more (one of the reasons I avoid any synthetic fabrics) make up this mix. Our society is based on petroleum by-products & bit by bit, it ends up in our soil & water throughout our environment. It's become far more complicated than simply not throwing away our garbage & cheerfully recycling things as the commercials from governments & industries would have us believe. It would require an entire restructuring of this world's economies, cultures & living standards as well as a different way of living that few would accept. Sorry... best shut up now.

v i d u n d e r l a n d says :1/Apr/2010 10:10:45
Such a touching story. Fishing nets ruin so many lives..

ScottS101 says :25/Nov/2009 01:55:13
Check out this story. Very similar.... www.saveourseas.com/manta-rescue

Sea Gal 18329 says :14/Aug/2009 20:43:24
Not me! I love hearing dive stories. Haha, I hope so too. Don't forget to tell them that I was also the first one in the water at night. It was creepy I'm glad none of the tigers followed us, I would have been first on the menu! Everytime I look at the pictures from the dive trip I want to be back on the boat. Were you ever on the boat while a girl named Melissa Johnson worked on it? Miss ya Sarah

ScottS101 says :14/Aug/2009 19:58:35
Sarah, I just saw your comment. I hope you get over your anger with me. Sometimes, when you just meet people on a dive trip you can overwhelm them with stories about your diving experiences. Sometimes people think you are bragging or trying to outdo their stories. Don't worry though, I am going to tell lots of people about the 13 year old girl I met in the Bahamas who dived with tiger sharks and was able to catch squid in her bare hands in the open sea at night! Hopefully, I'll still be telling the tale long after she grows up to be a renowned marine biologist!

Sea Gal 18329 says :28/Jul/2009 00:27:34
I'm glad you were able to help. That is a great story and I am upset with you for not telling it to me. I hope the manta ray lived and I am also saddened to see the killing of beautiful marine life.

wiggiewormdog says :16/Jul/2009 18:27:49
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called a new world, and we'd love to have this added to the group!

wiggiewormdog says :16/Jul/2009 18:27:15
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called THE BEST PHOTOS OF THE WORLD, and we'd love to have this added to the group!

SadClownofDeath says :23/Jun/2009 11:26:59
Awesome story. I commend you for at least attempting to help. I have to wonder what the rest of your dive mates were thinking about. I hope you learned your lesson about keeping your knife sharp! ;) You didn't mention his damaged feeding appendage. Were you able to free that?

alagus2008 says :15/Jun/2009 16:39:39
-

savemantas says :11/Jun/2009 19:54:12
An excellent story and witness to the intelligence of manta rays. Is it OK to post your story on the Save the Mantas blog?

♥ L i l a c ♥ says :28/Jan/2009 16:02:25
I hope he survived. I was very touched by this story. I am an environmentalist myself and am really concerned with the Great Pacific Garbage Patch We NEED to clean up after ourselves. Thank you so much for sharing this!! :)

Justin Ebert says :22/Jan/2009 03:46:37
Wow! Amazing story thanks for helping the poor creature out. I am so outraged at the destruction of our oceans in a global sense, but also angered for what this individual Manta had to endure. My experience has taught me that they really are some of the most intelligent and aware creatures in the ocean. Thank for sharing the story, it renews my drive to help create change!

ScottS101 says :8/Jan/2009 07:47:05
Thanks you all! I hope this story generates some support for all the sharks and rays out there.

gwernie says :7/Jan/2009 20:51:42
there needs to be more people like you on this earth. i applaud your attempt to help this poor soul. i hope he made it.

Tegan Howard says :2/Jan/2009 13:25:12
You are a very good person, there should be more people out there like yourself. Thanks for sharing this lovely story, I hope the Manta made it x

jb1562 says :20/Nov/2008 12:57:13
You just became a personal hero of mine! Am going to make sure my own diving knife always sharp!!!

Darrell Neo (Busy) says :6/Oct/2008 01:06:00
An awesome shot! It always makes us feels good whenever we help others, even try to help. =) Great courage and bravery!

makeupanid says :31/Aug/2008 15:32:04
The powers that be (that's me LOL) say yes! **************************************************** Congratulations! Voices in the Wilderness has choosen your image for our group icon. Great shot! ****************************************************

yeimaya says :26/Aug/2008 07:24:26
Right you are I will speak to the powers that be... is the mighty icon changer for Voices -- Seen on your photo stream. (?)

NovaP says :26/Aug/2008 05:15:37
God Bless You.

Chris - Tech Geek says :11/Aug/2008 11:46:00
It's over 7,000 Views Yeimaya :-)

rogierius says :11/Aug/2008 02:20:33
Amazing story!

Stephenography// says :30/Jul/2008 18:12:43
Thank you for sharing that story. This made your photo even more incredible. And thank you for taking on the extra risk to help this beautiful creature in need. I have tremendous respect for you. Regards, Stephen//

yeimaya says :26/Jul/2008 15:37:57
When You hit 7,000 let me know and we will make it the Voices icon for that week to celebrate! -- Seen in my recent comments. (?)

Chris - Tech Geek says :26/Jul/2008 15:04:29
Soon the everyone will know about your wonderful adventures Scott :-)

ScottS101 says :26/Jul/2008 14:46:29
FMC, We are approaching 7,000! :)

Chris - Tech Geek says :26/Jul/2008 12:14:03
WOW Scott over 6,000 people have view this photo!!

Judith Bakker says :26/Jul/2008 12:04:54
Wow, what a story! I hope he is still out there.

kitsuné says :22/Jul/2008 10:26:38
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Rays! (mantas and stingrays), and we'd love to have this added to the group! this is absolutely fabulous. I'm a huge environmentalist, my name is Lexi Bond, and it is horrible to see that the manta is in fact very entangled in that net. Not only would the net cause the manta physical pain, but it also goes to show that in the fishing industry, for every pound of seafood caught, 2 pounds of other sea animals die. But on the other hand it was beautifully captured and is now my desktop screensaver. Great work. Also-interesting story. I personally love writing as well.

Baptiste Lacoste says :21/Jul/2008 13:43:01
Hi, I'm an admin for a group called Testimony, and we'd love to have this added to the group!

Yome NetSan says :9/Jul/2008 05:10:33
Great shot ! Great story ! Thanks for trying to help, too bad you couldn't make it...

damps says :27/Jun/2008 22:52:32
its very sad to see this pictue good shot

solokingnz says :21/Jun/2008 03:05:33
Hi Scotts, Would it be possible to use it on our website as a title image? I am launching a community/environmental/human rights surf brand here in Australasia. We are fighting to highlight enviro-enlightenment, essentially make green very very cool. FlyBeach 'surf your green soul' will not be a non-for-profit but a high profit for environmental awareness, ready to launch next year, so i have limited funds to purchase the shot. But am open to price. regards Eden. solokingnz@yahoo.co.uk Ps: Very moving shot. I can almost here the Manta's sad silence!

ScottS101 says :17/Jun/2008 02:13:26
You are always right Gale! Bunbunz, I bought a much better knife! Semper paratus! And thanks for your kind words.

yeimaya says :16/Jun/2008 07:32:48
ah hem... hint hint Thanks for bringing this story up from the flickr depths once again! It is a very important story.

B u n b u n z says :16/Jun/2008 01:52:27
This Has to be the most moving story every to be told. To have basically risked your own life for another living creature. This literally brought tears to my eyes. How people could just sit and watch....It's just awful. I bet you, that manta would have loved to thank you for your attempt to save it's life. I could only imagine what suffering it must have went through. Thank you Scott.

Steven Benton Photography says :12/Jun/2008 16:05:26
great story although heart wrenching... well done for trying...

Powered by:
Powered by Flickr
News Release Agency (NRA)
Our mission is to collect all the news releases issued every day in the world about fishing and make them available to you, when, where and the way you need them.
Thank you all for supporting us!
Follow  on Twitter